I have gotten the imperfect box before and each time has goodies with hardly any noticeable defects. I love finding products I can tuck in to a gift or give to my kids for their homes. This time the mini potholders were perfect for our daughter’s new apartment and the mug will be the best gift for my sis-in-law. The defects aren’t noticeable at all. I did get 2 of the same tea towels, but I gave one to my daughter and kept the other for myself.